Monday, May 14, 2007
Professor Zhang's successes in Europe
To read more about the enthusiastic reception of Professor Zhang's New Approach, go here.
Western language acquisition theory inappropriate for Chinese
This blog may be new, but the idea that Western language acquisition theory is inappropriate for learning Chinese is not. You can visit here for more information.
Sunday, May 13, 2007
The ease and beauty of Chinese grammar
Chinese grammar is easier than that of any European language. Limited morphology means there is only one verb form no matter whether you are talking about the past, present or future and no matter who is the agent. There is no nominative, accusative or dative (one of the two banes of my existence when I was studying Latin, French, Italian and German).
我是 I am
你是 you are
他/她/它是 he/she/it is
我们是 we are
你们是 you are
他们是 they are
There is no masculine, feminine or neuter for nouns (the other bane of my existence).
Simple, elegant and easy to remember.
After the first 2 years of studying Chinese in Australia, I rarely made a grammatical error. There's just not that much to remember! I certainly can't say the same thing about any of the European languages I learnt when I was in High School. I truly sympathise with all students of English, many of whom after studying for 10 years or more still struggle with grammar and syntax.
Who said Chinese was hard to learn?
我是 I am
你是 you are
他/她/它是 he/she/it is
我们是 we are
你们是 you are
他们是 they are
There is no masculine, feminine or neuter for nouns (the other bane of my existence).
Simple, elegant and easy to remember.
After the first 2 years of studying Chinese in Australia, I rarely made a grammatical error. There's just not that much to remember! I certainly can't say the same thing about any of the European languages I learnt when I was in High School. I truly sympathise with all students of English, many of whom after studying for 10 years or more still struggle with grammar and syntax.
Who said Chinese was hard to learn?
The basic elements of written words
In English, words are made from combinations of the 26 letters of the alphabet. Before teaching children to write whole words, teachers focus on the ABCs. Once these "building blocks" are mastered, learning words becomes simply a matter of recognising which pattern of letters to use. The problem for the learner of English is that each word has a unique spelling.
Chinese characters are also made of basic elements. They are called "radicals". The vast majority of the tens of thousands of characters that can be written in Chinese use only about 200 radicals. Learning these elements makes the recognition of characters a much easier task and frees the learner to think about the meaning derived by putting the elements together. Characters that look incredibly daunting to the beginner, once broken into their constituent parts, become more manageable, meaningful and fascinating.
Examples:
日 character for sun
月 character for moon
明 character for brightness (the sun + the moon = bright)
女 character for woman
子 character for baby
好 character for good (a woman with her baby is good)
Add to this the fact that many words in Chinese are actually compounds of 2 or 3 characters and learning Chinese reading and writing suddenly seems much less intimidating. In fact it is the "modular" nature of Chinese that makes it so flexible. Take for example the character 学 which means "to study". It can be combined to make new words very easily:
A character may be added after
学生 student
A character may be added before
大学 university
Before AND after gives
大学生 university student
How beautiful!
Chinese characters are also made of basic elements. They are called "radicals". The vast majority of the tens of thousands of characters that can be written in Chinese use only about 200 radicals. Learning these elements makes the recognition of characters a much easier task and frees the learner to think about the meaning derived by putting the elements together. Characters that look incredibly daunting to the beginner, once broken into their constituent parts, become more manageable, meaningful and fascinating.
Examples:
日 character for sun
月 character for moon
明 character for brightness (the sun + the moon = bright)
女 character for woman
子 character for baby
好 character for good (a woman with her baby is good)
Add to this the fact that many words in Chinese are actually compounds of 2 or 3 characters and learning Chinese reading and writing suddenly seems much less intimidating. In fact it is the "modular" nature of Chinese that makes it so flexible. Take for example the character 学 which means "to study". It can be combined to make new words very easily:
A character may be added after
学生 student
A character may be added before
大学 university
Before AND after gives
大学生 university student
How beautiful!
Saturday, May 12, 2007
Spoken and Written Chinese - Two Systems
Even in a language like English, it's clear that spoken language and written language are different. Some people might argue that because written English is (at least partially) phonemic, its relationship with its spoken counterpart is quite close. If one forgets how to say a word, for example, a speaker will be able to remind themselves of how to pronounce it by looking at the written version.
However, written language is not a record of spoken language. If you asked someone to record your voice, they would think of modern audio equipment. Nor does written language require the same senses as spoken language. One requires the eye and the hand, the other, the ear and the mouth. Written language does not require reading aloud for the message to be understood. The deaf and mute have no barrier to understanding the written word. The blind have no trouble listening or speaking.
If this is the case for English, the difference between the two systems is even more obvious with Chinese. Chinese writing is logographic - each character is like a picture - and reading characters rarely aids pronunciation. To the beginner, it offers no help in this regard whatsoever. However, this can lead to a terrible misconception: the belief that Chinese is "difficult to learn". The nature of Chinese writing does make it a challenge. However, if taught in the right way, learning to read and write Chinese becomes enjoyable and interesting.
In fact, speaking and writing are just two different ways of expressing meaning. They should be taught separately using different methods. As Han Dynasty scholar Yang Xiong (杨雄) wrote, "Speaking is sound from the heart, writing is pictures from the heart" (言心声也书心画也) 《法言》.
However, written language is not a record of spoken language. If you asked someone to record your voice, they would think of modern audio equipment. Nor does written language require the same senses as spoken language. One requires the eye and the hand, the other, the ear and the mouth. Written language does not require reading aloud for the message to be understood. The deaf and mute have no barrier to understanding the written word. The blind have no trouble listening or speaking.
If this is the case for English, the difference between the two systems is even more obvious with Chinese. Chinese writing is logographic - each character is like a picture - and reading characters rarely aids pronunciation. To the beginner, it offers no help in this regard whatsoever. However, this can lead to a terrible misconception: the belief that Chinese is "difficult to learn". The nature of Chinese writing does make it a challenge. However, if taught in the right way, learning to read and write Chinese becomes enjoyable and interesting.
In fact, speaking and writing are just two different ways of expressing meaning. They should be taught separately using different methods. As Han Dynasty scholar Yang Xiong (杨雄) wrote, "Speaking is sound from the heart, writing is pictures from the heart" (言心声也书心画也) 《法言》.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
